Carly wasn't acting. It's a good thought but in the funfacts Dan explained that Carly is claustrophobic. In iPyscho it must have been a plot hole, but if it was me (as a claustrophobic) the space is big enough and their are holes in the door so I wouldn't be SO claustrophobic because at least their is a way of getting out of the door get's stuck or something.

Pretty good episode I say, I laughed quite a bit, especially on Freddie's storyline, which I wish could have been more drawn out, but I couldn't stop laughing at the scene in the Groovy Smoothie when they made his identity and location so obvious and Gunsmoke was really funny as a stereotype. I wish they had more Jane Lynch screen time, but she was funny in the scenes she was in, and was a good choice to play Sam's mom. The last make-up scene was funny, but Carly acting like a goat was really random, she could have acted the same way she did in the space pod, and I think trying to hear Sam and her mom make up over loud screaming and panicking would have been much funnier (at least to me). Overall though I'm impressed with this season and look forward to more.

Unlike most people the fact that Gibby is a main character bothers me. He hasn't had much development yet so I don't really know who his character is. Same goes for Carly, Spencer, Sam and Freddie. So before they added ANOTHER main character they should have developed the four slightly first...

I don't like Gibby as a main character, but I kind of want LESS of him. I adore Gibby, I do, but I like him showing up randomly more....like the first episode that he was in where he just ran into the detention room without a shirt screaming. He's grown up and changed, but I did like him better when he was little when he acted weirder. Now he's another normal kid who says some funny stuff. I really liked the iCarly trio dynamic. I actually didn't mind Gibby only being there in the beginning. I liked that better than the "Gibby getting his grandfather to give Spencer a haircut" storyline. I'm still not used to him being there. "Less is more. CHA CHA CHA, Charmin!"

I don't know why, but the Shadow Hammer reminded me of the episode of "Drake and Josh" where everybody thought Josh was the criminal. Maybe it was because both of the criminals seemed similar since they both robbed cash registers? I kind of wanted Freddie to put on weird disguises like that afro in iKiss so he wouldn't recognize him. I was concerned with the fact that criminals are usually cunning and smart to be able to outsmart so many people. So I thought it was weird that he didn't notice that the apartment numbers(from left to right alternating between the sides of the hall) would go C, H, E, F, G, D. I thought he wouldn't have fallen for it and would look for him, but I still thought it was funny. I assume they won't see him again, but maybe he will be referenced in a future episode? Like the prisoners in iTTK, Melanie, Wade Collins, etc. I kind of liked him, haha.

I find T-Bo hilarious. They are showing him an awful lot now. I don't want him to be a regular either, I just want him to have as much of a part of iCarly as he does now. "Buy 12 smoothies and get the 13th one for 10% off!" LOL and then it expired the next day. Love it.

I think it is funny how people are talking about Gibby, but ignoring what went on yesterday... I liked Gibby because in Ipsycho and before this episode Gibby was still a "kid" lol and that is why he was funnier... BUT if you did not notice yesterday... Gibby is now taller and his voice changed a bit and he looked like he lost a little, not much, but a little weight... hahaha

I think this episode clearly showed me that we are headed for a showdown between Freddie & his mom before the series ends. We now have a clearer understanding at least of the relationship between Sam & her mom, & I think they will do something similar with Freddie and his mom. This episode shows that Freddie is treated the same way by his mom as he was at the beginning of the series, there has to be a resolution & explanation of why she is so protective to the extreme. Freddie has to snap at some point IMO.

Good episode, Jane Lynch was cast perfectly as Sam's mom, like I thought before. She did a great job in all of her scenes. I thought the claustrophobia thing was unrealistic too, but there are varying degrees and types of claustrophobia. The scenes with the robber were funny too XP

i just rewatched the episode lol and again it amazed me how much i enjoyed the freddie subplot. While i did like pam and sam and finally getting to see them interact, for me the freddie storyline stole the show. Every scene of it had me loling like crazy. A pleasant surprise since prior to the premiere i was mainly focused on sam's