Why would anyone in the audience expect them to confirm they were dating even if they were? The web show is one thing their personal lives are another matter, and something they wouldn't want to share with fans at a convention IMO.

^Well the people at school weren't at Webicon, and it's only the people at Webicon who are all insane nerds. The fans of iCarly at school probably aren't such freaks.

People should know about iSYL anyways though since Freddie blogged about it on iCarly.com. He said one of the good things about being hit by a taco truck was that Carly kissed him.

He said that getting hit by a taco truck is one of the greatest things that has ever happened to him and wrote,
"Oh, yeah, and I totally got all smoochy with Carly! (That's all you're getting from me on that subject... A gentleman never blogs on his love life. But we DID kiss and it was GLORIOUS!)"

Like Lamp said, I don't know if it should be counted though...

The thing about it is I've looked for a topic on the subject on the groovy smoothie and here and they barely even touched on it. In fact the other thing I thought was interesting was that they were discussing that one iCarly CD that has extra tracks of the group chatting and whether that should be counted or not.

tvtropes says: "A related term is Duetercanon, which in this context refers to those persons, places and/or events which are not explicitly shown on-screen, but which are considered "official" or close to it."

I think iCarly.com would come under this category. One of the premises (if not the premise) is that these kids produce a webshow and that means that you'd have to incorporate some aspects of the website content into canon. Most of the things I've viewed on the website do not contradict what we've seen in the show so I think Dueterocanon is a proper term for it. (In fact sometimes things are confirmed; such as VC pointed out in Freddie's blog).

I'm still confused though...;-; I'm pretty sure if I spent a whole on this and researched a couple things I could come up with a viable theory that would also be ranting. I don't know if I have energy for that though. lol

Well ICarly.com is a website setup for the show so it may count as part of the iCarly story, but only if Dan decides what is posted there as coming from the characters. If it's like the promo's Nick puts together then it doesn't count IMO.

Wow, I haven't been here in a while... Anyway, IStartA Fan War was... alright. I kinda just agree with what everyone else said, "the main plot was boring, Spencer vs. Jack Black was Epicness (which it was), Gibby and Guppy were annoying and pointless, etc... Aside from that though:

♦ I had a fangirl moment when Craig and Eric walked in. I was like, "OMG, IT'S THEM!!!!!! FROM DRAKE AND JOSH!!!!!!" And then Gavin made it even better. I love seeing characters from other shows make appearances. (well, that is if I know who they are) It feels like I'm seeing friends I never thought I'd see again.

♦ I loved the Aruthor vs. Aspartamay battle. I loved how they all knew so much about the other one's costume but each had fatal flaws on their own. The dialoque between Jack and Jerry was excellent. I honestly would like to see them try to do something like that, unscripted. Like a "Whose Line is it Anyway?" type thing? (Love that show) Anyway, I think the song was also quite catchy. I almost felt the need to put it on my Ipod.

♦ I thought it was a little weird (and a bit of a let-down) how they all already knew about seddie/creddie. Like when Carly's talking to Adam on her computer and she's like, "Yeah, Creddie shippers want me and Freddie to get together, and Seddie shippers want Sam and Freddie to get together" or whatever. Like,..cuz,...and...THEY'VE NEVER MENTIONED THIS BEFORE!?!?! You'd think they would've at least made it clear on their webshow that none of them were dating! I got the impression that they never knew! And I was looking forward to the moment when they would all find out and the awkwardness that would ensue... Oh well...

♦You gotta love how we were portrayed. "Oh, look, their elbows are touching...THAT MEANS THEY'RE IN LOVE!" If I remember right, people have actually said things along those lines on other forums. Wow. Also, I found it a little creepy that there were actual grown men there, but ... that's ICarly for ya.

♦ Why are people getting so worked up over Carly's speech? At first, I was mad too. Like, "How dare you tell us that we shouldn't ship fictional characters?" Because, for me, that's mostly why I watch the show. I mean, there's not many heartfelt moments orcharacter development like there is in other shows. ICarly is supposed to be all about comedy, but to me, it's not really that funny except for Spencer. When you use random humour too much it stops being random, and, stops being funny. The webshow itself is just pathetic too. C'mon, if ICarly were a real webshow hosted by normal kids, no one would watch it. The only really funny skits I can think of are "Great Moments in Kid History: The First Tantrum" and of course "Kelly Cooper: Terrible Movie" So yeah, at first Carly's speech annoyed me. I thought Dan was trying to tell us how stupid we are, but if you notice, the second Carly's done talking, people start right up again with the fanwar, making Carly's speech seem almost like nothing more than a gag, just like the one in that episode where everyone was crammed inside their apartment during the heat wave, when Carly makes the speech about how they should all just get along and then, as soon as the air conditioning comes back on, everyone pushes past eachother to get out. So, I don't really think it meant anything.

♦ And lastly,...Okay, so promise me we won't start a completely unrelated fanwar on an ICarly forum? Okay... so since Avatar (The Last Airbender) WAS a Nickelodeon show,...I was kinda hopin' someone would at least allude to the Kataang/Zutara shipping war, like one of the fans would say something like, "Well, at least we aren't as bad as the Zutarians and Kataangers..." Just like mutter it under their breath or something. I thought it would've been hilarious, don't you?I mean, they made allusions to Drake & Josh, right?

Anyway, review over, rant over, Evening_Haze: out.

Late to comment here, but I just saw this for the first time today and I'm not going to lie. iStart A Fan War might be my favorite iCarly TV movie/episode of the entire series. Spencer and Jack Black nerd war was amazing,Guppy and Gibby's grandfather actually make Gibby way more entertaining to me and I am one who actually enjoyed the main plot for what it was.

Also, I don't why but that guy with the yellow 'Seddie' shirt got a laugh out of me all the times he yelled: SEDDIE!!!