The thing is that almost every Total Drama fan hates those two for being a 'jerk'. Those are the people that you know who've never watched a reality show before. Heather lasts long because she's the character with the most potential. You could make 15 seasons of TD with Heather and Alejandro in themand they won't get boring, whilst characters like Owen, Izzy, Gwen, Cody and such get boring and derailed after only lasting a season-and-a-half on the show.

Let's have a look at the most popular characters, shall we?

Duncan: Done to death, they created a rushed attempt of creating a love triangle to give him some airtime, was a waste of a time. Duncan should have quit the show and never come back in the first place. Why not keep him a mystery? Why couldn't he stay 'escaped' and never come back? That would create drama and give you the idea that Duncan is possibly a retired character or that he could come back at any given time should the circumstances permit. Even how they found him was rushed. Did Duncan really have enough time to go from Egypt to Canada, bring his band and THEN go to London in such a short amount of time?

DJ...Ugh, DJ. He's the character that explains the word 'decent'. However, they focus too much on the animals and his mom to focus on his role of any sort in the show. In World Tour he was a disaster after being decent in the two previous seasons.

Ezekiel? Turned into Gollum. Basicially saying they have no idea what they want to do with him in the first place.

Geoff and Bridgette are now crazed-hosting characters, especially the former. I still love them both but I'd like to see them COMPETE thanks.

Owen, a fart-machine that's been expired for nearly a year now. Same for Izzy, her crazy-nature's been done.

I could go on and on...but the new characters will hopefully be a fresh experience. I'll always like the original characters better, no matter what, but a season/calendar year without them? Almost like a vacation of some sort.

I definitely want to see Eva compete in another season. In "The Big Sleep", it was shown that she could be a nicer person behind her tough exterior, but the writers seemed to forget about that in "No Pain No Game" and she hasn't shown any emotions since aside from violent anger. She is in desperate need of more character development.

As for Katie and Sadie...I can't stand them. Still, it would be interesting to see them in another season as well.

Here what the boot order should of been for TDI

TDI:

22: Ezekiel shuts up and Courtney is eliminated.

21: Heather forms her alliance like before. Eva is still eliminated

20: Lindsay sucks at Dodgebrawl, Harold gets the Bass the win. Although Noah is targeted, he forms an alliance with Owen, Izzy, Cody, Trent, and Leshawna. They all vote off Lindsay and she is sent home. (NOTE: Noah is the new main antagonist)

19: Harold is able to gain victory for the Bass again. Heather panics without Lindsay. Noah and his crew target Beth due to her likeability and weakness in challenges and she is sent home.

18: At the camping challenge, Katie and Sadie lose it for the Bass. Sadie goes home this time.

17: At the phobia challenge, Tyler is able to overcome his fear of chickens and wins it for the Bass. Noah targets Heather due to her being a threat and she is sent home. Katie panics without Sadie, but starts to get over it. Heather's alliance is completely destroyed.

16: Since Beth isn't here, she can't curse the team and the Gophers win. Noah hears that the Bass are targeting Harold but he intervenes and gets Duncan eliminated due to him having an upper hand at later challenges.

15: At the paintball challenge, Owen gets enraged at Harold when he called him obese. He begins a conflict with him. Noah was eating a bag of sour cream potato chips and left in in the middle of the woods. Ezekiel gets his hands on them and is still hungry. He snabs some berries, but a bear mauls him and puts him in a body cast. He must be evacuated because of this injury.

14: Katie shows off her cooking skills and makes a perfect ribs and creme broulee. Noah gets locked in a freezer by Gwen who suspects he is up to something. Despite this, he targets her and Gwen is sent home.

13: Noah is happy he got rid of Gwen and plans to get rid of Justin next as he is the only person left on the Gophers who is not in his alliance. However, the Gophers win and since Geoff cheated at the sledding challenge, he is unanimously booted.

12: DJ continuously messes up at the boot camp challenges and he is on the chopping block. However, to everyones shock, he switches the votes to Katie and she is sent home instead.

11: At the extreme sports, DJ pillow dives perfectly and Harold manages to win the mudskiing challenge. As the only not alliance member left on the gophers, Justin is voted off.

10: The merge occours and its Boy's Vs. Girls. The boys manage to pull off a victory due to Owen's tolerance for disgusting food.

10 boot: To everyone's horror, two people return to the game. Duncan and Eva come back with a vengeance. Duncan continuously gets angry at everyone and due to his ferocious temper, he is sent home again.

New 11: Noah sees a budding romance between Leshawna and Harold. So Noah lies that Harold doesnt like her and kisses Leshawna. Everyone thinks Harold is a jerk and he is booted.

New 10: Bridgette is booted due to her likeability.

9: At the bike racing contest, Owen comes in last. Noah shows no remorse and Owen flips off at him. He bids farewell to everyone.

8: Noah sees Cody's likeability as threat and he is booted

7: Izzy is still eliminated after Noah is tranquilized.

6: Noah knows Tyler is well liked and he is booted.

5: At playa de losers no one wants Noah to win. Everyone unintentionally says Leshawna's name is she is booted

4: Trent is well liked and Noah wont accept this and he goes home'

3: Noah has to do the owrst thing in his life, shave his head. He refuses but the razor falls on him and he ends up bald. He is officialy out.

2: It's DJ and Eva. Dj makes it across and is the winner of Total drama island. and Noah gets locked in the confession.

Hmm... I liked it. It's sort of the same as TDI, but different in a way. You made Noah the main character/Antagonist, since many fans like him.The only thing I disliked was Cody was voted off (I'm a Cody Fan). At least DJ can buy his mom a ticket to Jamacia, even though she's a evil leech.

So, in your version, DJ cheats and tampers with the votes instead of Harold...and then he WINS!?

Assuming your using all the episodes/plots of Island...

TDI:

Now here's TDA differently

TDDDDI: DJ, Noah, Courtney, Leshawna, Izzy, Cody, Bridgette, Harold, Duncan, Gwen, Ezekiel, Heather, Owen, and Lindsay make it to TDA.

NOTE: There will be NO reward challenges in my version.

14: Cody and Bridgette win immunity. Double boot. Deciding that he needs to compensate for last season and not get fooled easily, Cody gets everyone to eliminate Lindsay and Owen as they are well liked, yet not good in challenges.(Cody is the main antagonist this season)

12: Cody and Bridgette are the team captains for Screaming Gaffers and Killer Grips. Cody picks Duncan, Courtney, DJ, Heather and Harold.

Bridgette chooses Gwen, Noah, Leshawna, Izzy, Gwen, and Ezekiel. The teams have to put on an acting challenge. Duncan's uncanny ability to act wins in for the Gaffers. Cody makes an alliance with DJ, Harold and Duncan. Izzy is eliminated for screwing up the challenge.

11: Wild West. The Grips manage to pull of a victory since Trent isn't there and can't throw challenges. Courtney is targeted and eliminated by Cody's alliance.

10: Owen returns. The Gaffers win due to Leshawna slowing the Grips up. Owen is put on the grips. Leshawna is eliminated.

New 10: Horror. Owen scares the crap out of the Gaffers and they must vote someone off. Cody eliminates Heather due to her being his match at strategizing.

9: War. The Grips lose due to Owen injuring his ankle. He gets blindsided. DJ starts to distrust Cody.

8: Bank heist. Eva debuts in the game. Noah manages to drive the go kart to the finish line for the Grips. Eva is put on the gaffers. Her vote is the only valid one and she eliminates Duncan with it.

New 8: Sports. It is revealed that Bridgette insulted the Grips behind their back. They are angry with her. However. Due to cheerleading, Noah gets booted instead.

7: Merge. Superheroes. Cody wins as Mysterion. (I know I copied from South Park). He lies to Ezekiel that the girls want to vote him off and he votes for Bridgette. Along with the other votes, Bridgette bids her farewells.

6: Knights. Ezekiel gets tricked by Courtney and he gets severely injured when falling 30 feet. He must be evacuated due to injuries AGAIN.

5: Rockstars. Duncan returns. Harold proves he is a true rocker and gets immunity. Everyone wants to get rid of Duncan, but since Courtney wasnt paying attention and unintentionally votes for herself. She is eliminated.

New 5: Space. Scruffy, Duncan's pet spider is accidently crushed by Harold. Duncan is so upset about losing Scruffy, that he wants him out. But Cody, knowing he could gain votes from this gets Duncan eliminated instead.

4/3: Cody gets DJ and Gwen eliminated because he could gain jury votes from Harold being a goat

Final 2: Cody pleads to the jury that he played a strong strategical game and tried his best to be friends with everyone. Everyone believes what Cody said. Harold says that he thought that he wanted to be friends with everyone and did not backstab anyone. When it came down to the vote. Noah, Bridgette, Courtney and Duncan vote for Cody and he is declared the winner of Total Drama Action.

I liked where this was going: Making Cody the winner. But the only theme I'm getting from you is that you want only Antagonists to win.

I understand this. I am doing this to make it more realistic like a actual reality show. And DJ wasn't the antagonist in my version of TDI.

Off Topic

So what you're saying is that most reality shows make the villians win? That's a load of... wait! DJ was a minor Antagonist in your first Season (Tampering with the votes and got Katie eliminated).

On Topic

Go Cody!

"Total Drama Island" What-If Part One; If Sierra and Alejandro were in Season 1: Episode 1, Teams are the same as before, with Sierra on the Screaming Gopher's Team and Alejandro on the Killer Bass Team; Sierra doesn't have a fan-girl crush on Cody since he's not famous yet, but she still thinks he's cute; Alejandro is still a manipulator, but slightly less antagonistic since he wasn't lied to about "Total Drama Scumbags." Episode 2, Izzy switches places with Katie so she can be on the Killer Bass with Sadie; Alejandro partners up with Ezekiel and coaches him about how to act around girls; although Alejandro initially wants to get rid of Courtney, he sees that D.J. would be a bigger threat due to his strength and likability ESPECIALLY if he ever stopped being a coward, so Alejandro gets together a voting bloc of Katie, Sadie, Eva, Ezekiel, Tyler, Bridgette, and Duncan to vote off D.J.; D.J. is eliminated from the game as the Screaming Gophers win. Episode 3, Sierra stays up the longest instead of Gwen, Cody develops a crush on her instead of Gwen, Alejandro PRETENDS to like Eva and soothes her so that when she finds out her MP3 player is missing, she doesn't freak out and threaten people; instead Alejandro uses the theft to garner sympathy for Eva so that when Heather returns the MP3 player, her plan has backfired because of Alejandro; Heather starts to see Alejandro as a threat; Ezekiel confides in Courtney that he doesn't want to vote off Harold, yet he doesn't want to get backlash from Alejandro by not voting with him; Courtney takes Ezekiel's voting job and votes off Harold so that when the votes are tallied (but no announcements about which contestant voted from whom) Alejandro doesn't realize anything is off as the votes have come out the way Alejandro wanted them to. Harold is eliminated as being the weakest Killer Bass member for falling asleep first.

Episode 4, Noah is enraged by the way Alejandro is getting his way with most of the Killer Bass, and is determined NOT to be eliminated by THAT scumbag; Noah extends an alliance opportunity to Heather and says that with their combined brain power, they will be able to defeat Alejandro and wipe that smirk off his face; Noah decides to play instead of Lindsay, and does SLIGHTLY better than Lindsay would've, but only because Noah knows what he is doing. Since Gwen isn't exhausted, she also plays a killer game; the Screaming Gophers win the first two rounds, when Alejandro, who has let his fellow team-mates do the playing up until now, decides to take his turn and says that the Killer Bass don't need to wake Duncan up in order to win this challenge, as Alejandro wants to use this opportunity to try to get Courtney attracted to him instead of Duncan; Alejandro utilizes Duncan's secret technique, and the Killer Bass win rounds 3 & 4; in the final round, the final contestants left are Owen against Ezekiel, but Ezekiel manages to catch Owen's killer dodge-ball, finally becoming seen as a valuable player to the Killer Bass by scoring them their first win; Heather realizes her chances of winning would be FAR better having Noah and Beth but not Lindsay on her team. So Noah, Izzy, Cody, Beth, Sierra, Heather, and Owen (via cake bribery) vote Lindsay off, eliminating her from the game. Episode 5, Justin notices that Alejandro is just as good at charming women as he is, determined to NOT let Alejandro 1-up him in the charming department, Justin devises his special basketball skills (seen in TDA's "Million Dollar Babies") to use in the talent contest instead of his beauty; Sierra annoys Heather MORE than Gwen, as Heather is sickened by Sierra's endless talk about Cody and the love crush he has on her; Heather steals Sierra's diary while Noah stands look-out; Justin's basketball skills earn him a 9 just like Trent's singing (no change); Courtney goes on first instead of last due to Alejandro's insistence, she only scores a 5 which REALLY ticks her off, and Alejandro realizes that Courtney's rage could be REALLY useful to him in the future; meanwhile, Katie and Sadie get to Go-Go dance second AGAIN due to Alejandro's insistence, and actually score an 8 from Chef; Heather reads Sierra's diary which talks about Sierra's feelings with Cody in a very intimate detail, Noah feels Heather went too far for her petty payback, and Noah begins to have second thoughts about having Heather in HIS alliance; after Geoff breaks his skateboard, Tyler improvises by using his incredible finger strength to bench-press 50 pound weights, scoring the Killer Bass a 10 and winning them the challenge; Alejandro starts to see Tyler as a useful member in his alliance; Justin senses that he and Heather both share the same hatred against Alejandro, so Justin offers Heather a chance to swap out the members of HER alliance to join up with Justin INSTEAD of Noah, Heather's new voting bloc votes off LaShawna for her AWFUL dancing seen BEFORE the talent contest (tricked into doing it by Alejandro); and LaShawna is voted off and sent home; Gwen decides to get vengeance on Sierra's behalf, and dumps Duncan's collection of pet spiders (including Scruffy) onto Heather while she's sleeping in her bed. /

I'll continue with my What-If scenario the next time I post here. Enough said!

Indent a little more next time please. (My eyes hurt from reading that lol.)

Interesting what-if scenario, though.