Actually, we see Geoff asleep when the counter for the Bass says "4" Courtney is still up then.
If Courtney wasn't strong enough to be a threat, who was? It's been established that she did better in all of the challenges besides Duncan, granting her second place. She never got a chance to be considered a threat due to voting because she didn't make it to the merger due to Harold's cheating.
I wonder how the other campers stack up? Let's compare the ones the others to each other.
Bridgette vs. Harold
1.) Tie, both jump
2.) Harold outlasts Bridgette (she is the first asleep) 0-1
3.) Tie. Harold caught the final ball to win the last round, but Bridgette participated in victory in the fourth round with the blitz strategy.
4.) Harold wins. 0-2
5.) Tie, neither did anything of note. Burning down the tent does not factor (it might even be considered helpful if it helped them wake up early)
6.) Tie, both failed their stunts
7.) Harold burned the oars, costing the team, 1-2
8.) Tie, both hunters shot deer
9.) It might seem like a tie, but I'd say Bridgette slighty ekes out since Harold kept leaving to change his clothes. Not enough for a score, however.
10.) Bridgette wins, she succeeded in two challenges to Harold's one. 2-2.
11.) Harold outlasts Bridgette, 2-3.
12.) Harold costs the team the challenge, so Bridgette wins. 3-3.
DJ vs. Harold
1.) Harold wins, as DJ failed the challenge. 0-1
2.) Harold wins, as DJ falls asleep earlier. 0-2
3.) DJ wins, as he wins two rounds while Harold wins one. 1-2
4.) Harold wins. 1-3
5.) Tie, neither does anything of note.
6.) DJ wins, he completes phobia while Harold does not. 2-3
7.) DJ wins, he pushes team to victory while Harold burns the oars. 3-3
8.) Harold wins. DJ backs himself into a corner on the cliff, and it was only luck that Owen ran out of bullets. 3-4
9.) Tie, although a slight edge can be given to DJ, since Harold kept leaving to change his clothes.
10.) Harold wins, DJ costs the team the challenge while Harold succeeds. 3-5.
11.) Harold wins, he outlasts DJ. 3-6.
12.) DJ wins, as Harold costs the team the challenge. 4-6
Geoff vs. Harold
1.) Tie, both jump off cliff.
2.) Tie, we don't see one outlast the other
3.) Geoff wins, as he won two rounds to Harold's one. 1-0
4.) Harold wins, 1-1
5.) Tie, neither did anything of note.
6.) Tie, both failed their phobias.
7.) Harold cost the team by burning oars, moreso then Geoff's injury. 2-1
8.) Tie, both hunters shot the deer
9.) Geoff wins, as he assigned recipes and chose the course of the menu. 3-1
10.) Geoff wins, he won two challenges to Harold's one (DJ merely disqualified him) 4-1.
11.) Geoff outlasts Harold, 5-1.
12.) Tie, both campers failed their challenges.
Bridgette vs. Geoff
1.) Tie, both jumped off the cliff
2.) Geoff wins, he outlasted Bridgette. 0-1
3.) Geoff wins, he won two rounds to Bridgette's one. 0-2
4.) Bridgette wins. Geoff broke his own skateboard, costing him the round. Bridgette participated, and Bridgette led the team to choose Harold with Courtney. 1-2.
5.) Tie, neither does anything of note.
6.) Tie, both campers fail challenge
7.) Bridgette wins, as Geoff slowed the team down due to his injury. 2-2
8.) Tie, both campers shot deer
9.) Geoff wins, as he led the team to victory assigning dishes. 2-3.
10.) Bridgette wins, as she completed two challenges while Geoff succeeded at one. 3-3
11.) Geoff outlasts Bridgette, 4-3.
12.) Bridgette wins, as Geoff failed his challenge. 4-4.
Bridgette vs. Courtney
1.) Bridgette wins, as Courtney doesn't complete the challenge. 1-0
2.) Courtney outlasts Bridgette 1-1
3.) Courtney wins. Both win one round, but she coerces Duncan to participate, and throws out more campers. 1-2
4.) Courtney wins, as Bridgette hits her with a stage light and knocks the strong player out. 1-3
5.) Tie, neither did anything of note
6.) Tie, both fail their challenge
7.) Neither did anything special, but Courtney seemed to get a slight edge because of her work with the fire.
8.) Tie, Courtney wasn't shot and Bridgette scored points.
9.) Tie, both dishes went over smoothly.
10.) Bridgette wins, she wins two challenges and Courtney fails hers. 2-3
11.) Courtney outlasts Bridgette, 2-4.
Bridgette vs. DJ
1.) Bridgette wins, as DJ doesn't jump. 1-0
2.) DJ outlasts Bridgette. 1-1
3.) DJ wins. He wins two rounds to Bridgette's one. 1-2
4.) Tie, both campers get the same score. Bridgette gets a slight edge for bringing Harold in.
5.) Tie, neither does anything of note.
6.) DJ wins, he completes his phobia and Bridgette doesn't. 1-3
7.) DJ pushes the team back to victory. 1-4
8.) Bridgette wins, as DJ backed himself into a corner at the cliff and Bridgette scored. 2-4
9.) Tie, they were both on the same team and got the same score.
10.) Bridgette wins, as DJ costs the team the challenge. 3-4
11.) Bridgette wins, as she outlasts DJ (he is eliminated when she is still in the contest) 4-4.
12.) Bridgette wins, DJ costs his team the challenge. 5-4.
DJ vs. Geoff
1.) Geoff wins, as DJ doesn't jump 0-1
2.) Geoff wins, as DJ is seen falling asleep first. 0-2
3.) Tie, both win two rounds.
4.) DJ wins, as Geoff breaks his skateboard. 1-2
5.) Tie, neither does anything of note
6.) DJ wins, he completes his phobia and Geoff doesn't. 2-2
7.) DJ pushes the team back and Geoff gets injured. 3-2.
8.) Geoff wins, as DJ backs himself into a corner and is saved by luck. 3-3.
9.) Geoff wins, as he leads the team to victory. 3-4.
10.) Geoff wins, as DJ costs the team the challenge. 3-5.
11.) Geoff outlasts DJ. 3-6.
12.) DJ completes his challenge, Geoff doesn't. 4-6
Courtney vs. DJ
1.) Tie, both fail the challenge.
2.) Courtney outlasts DJ. 1-0
3.) Courtney wins. DJ has two rounds to her one, but she coerces Duncan to participate and give the winning strategy. 2-0
4.) Courtney wins, as she brings in Harold and DJ messes up his stunt. 3-0
5.) Tie, neither did anything of note.
6.) DJ completes his phobia and Courtney doesn't. 3-1
7.) DJ pushes team to victory. 3-2
8.) Courtney wins. DJ backs himself into a corner and is saved by luck, and Courtney isn't shot at all. 4-2.
9.) Tie, both dishes are received well.
10.) Courtney wins, DJ fails two challenges and she fails one. 5-2.
11.) Courtney outlasts DJ. 6-2.
Courtney vs. Geoff
1.) Geoff wins, he jumps off the cliff and Courtney doesn't. 0-1
2.) Courtney outlasts Geoff. 1-1
3.) Courtney wins. Geoff participates in two rounds to her one, but she coerces Duncan to participate. 2-1
4.) Courtney wins, Geoff screws up his stunt, and Courtney brings in Harold. 3-1.
5.) Tie, neither did anything of note.
6.) Tie, both failed their stunts.
7.) Geoff injures himself and slows the team down, Courtney wins. 4-1
8.) Tie, Courtney is not shot by the opposing team and Geoff scores points for his.
9.) Geoff wins, he leads the teams to victory. 4-2.
10.) Geoff wins. Courtney fails her stunt and he succeeds at his two. 4-3.
11.) Courtney outlasts Geoff. 5-3.
Courtney vs. Duncan (Has to be done to see who's really on top)
1.) Duncan wins, as Courtney doesn't jump while he does. 0-1
2.) Duncan outlasts Courtney. 0-2
3.) Tie. Duncan's strategy won the game, but Courtney coerced him to actually use it.
4.) Courtney wins, as she brought out Harold and Duncan did nothing. 1-2.
5.) Tie, neither did anything of note.
6.) Duncan wins, Courtney doesn't complete her fear and he does. 1-3
7.) Duncan wins, as he brought the lighter to speed the challenge along. 1-4
8.) Tie, both are deer who are not shot.
9.) Tie, both were on the same team.
10.) Tie, both failed their stunt.
11.) Courtney outlasts Duncan. 2-4.
(I'll post the results in an easier to read section)