Here's mine:
Season 1: Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy- I'm sorry, but personally I'm not a fan of MM and BB episodes even though a couple of them were awesome.
Season 2: This is a hard one. I'll say Survival of the Idiots just because it's overrated to me and frankly sort of gross. I don't really dislike it, though.
Season 3: Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy 4- Like I've said before, I'm not a fan of MM and BB eps, and this one was ruined with its violence and bodily humor. You don't normally see this in earlier seasons.
Season 4: Um, Karate Island. It wasn't funny at all to me. The humor was forced, it was very creepy, and I have no idea how it got voted #1 in the Best Day Ever Countdown.
Season 5: It used to be To Love a Patty, but something happened to me recently that made me laugh at the scene with the fire the last time I saw it, so now it's Atlantis Squarepantis. It was overhyped, it focused mainly on the stupid tour, and there was too much singing and hardly anything funny and exciting about it at all. My apologies to the people who liked this episode.
Season 6: The Splinter- It was by far the most disgusting episode of Spongebob ever known to man, and it wasn't funny to me at all. Again, my apologies to the people who liked it.
Season 7: It was Chum Bucket Supreme for a little while, but now it's Sand Castles in the Sand. I used to like it okay, but now, frankly, I don't. It's extremely overrated and not funny enough in my opinion. It was also kind of boring to me, too unrealistic for my liking, and too out of character. Let's also not forget the fact that it had that gross gag, Patrick ripping off his skin. That was very disturbing and unpleasant. (look above at last sentence of my season 6 answer)
Edited on 08/07/2009 12:33pm