@83optics, don't you mean the Aflac duck? I liked the episode. It was good.

That was a great episode. Probably my favourite yet. I think it was right for Sam and Freddie to break up, but I love the implication that they probably will get back together in the future. I also couldn't help but love Spencer's subplot. But Gibby's? Didn't like it. It felt like they were forcing a storyline on Gibby as a second thought.

What?! YOU DIDN'T LIKE GIBBY AND THE DUCK? *slaps you* You have no taste...

I really liked this episode. It was funny. Freddie's club was so funny. Those people remind me a couple of people I see everyday. I didn't want them to break up, but it kind of made you think they got back together though.

Oh, and @83optics, yeah, I was looking at it and was like, "No.....Geico doesn't have a duck. It's Aflac." It's okay though.

After I saw this, I was left mind-blown. It was sort of depressing. But semi-sweet at the same time (like, when they said, "I love you," to each other). And I sort of agree with the whole "Freddie needed to watch what he said" thing. But for a somewhat different reason. I just felt like when he said some of the more blunt things, it was kind of unnatural. Like, when Freddie said, "It's not your fault. Carly's the one who told us to try things together." That still means "It's not completely your fault...you did have some help." It felt like one of those episodes that could be taken more serious/dramatic, but it's still a comedy so they have to make jokes about things to lighten the mood or whatever and the producers weren't necessarily analyzing it that much. Kind of like iSYL in a way (on that note, at least).

It was SURPRISINGLY excellent. I was expecting an awful episode since Season 5 has been unwatchable lately but this episode actually gave me some laughs. Not to sound mean but I'm super glad that Sam and Freddie broke up because they honestly have NO chemistry in my eyes at least.

Agreed, Sam torturing Freddie doesn't mean shipping time. Sam tortures Gibby too, so where are the freaking Sibbiers?

Not bad. So they broke up, or did they?

Very iSYL like, though.

And Katy, if you ever read this, Creddie is back in the race, IMO. Although, the sincere I Love You'd put seddie still a little bit ahead,

( please don't "answer" the first line. I was trying to sound mysterious as if the didnt make it obvious. . )

Carly's lines and Seddie's reaction to em made me think of the Creddies here

Are you sure you're not trying to turn whatever little thing you have into a boyfriend/girlfriend connection?

The Creddiers form a few months ago would be having a party when they heard their opinion voiced in canon lol

Nah, their opinion was that Carly needs to snatch up Freddie either immediately after, or just before, his break up with Sam, and screw her feelings whatsoever.

Maybe neither of them really is good for Freddie. Like, maybe Dan did this whole thing just to get all the crazy Creddiers and Seddiers to take it easy a little bit. I feel like with this arc thing and iSYL, he made them to show what would happen if Freddie dated either girl. And that's what ended up happening. IMO.

I don't know. It's possible that Dan DID initially give both couples a chance but obviously since he can't predict the audience's reaction, he had to film a certain number of episodes with Seddie together and then broke them up just in case the reaction wasn't what he expected. (Personally, I think he should have given Carly and Freddie a couple of more episodes of dating to even this all out...and I'm not even a Creddie fan). However, I felt like Seddie has a much more likely chance of happening again than Creddie. DON'T YELL AT ME CREDDIE FANS! Here's why: the ending that Dan gave Sam and Freddie was very much open ended. Even though they're broken up, they still both admitted their feelings, which means that both clearly care about each other a lot and they simply can't go back to hating each other. There's no way that they can go back to normal without making them OOC, as they are now friends (even more than friends). Freddie admitted that he loves Sam and Sam told him the exact same. So, for me, this is just a sign that they will possibly get back together at some point. Also, the fact that Freddie and Sam both mentioned that they would wait until they were both ready for a relationship.


But for Creddie, Carly admitted herself that maybe she developed false feelings for him because he saved her life. She kissed him on the cheek and that was that. I believe there was a mention of maybe trying it again in the future but I think that was mostly just to appease the fans. It didn't seem genuine enough and they started their relationship under false pretense IMO. It's not to say that they're hopeless and should never get together (because I feel they should give it one more chance to see if it could actually go somewhere and if the feelings are real). I just don't think they would ever truly get back together, as they are better friends than anything.