If it wasn't for Guppy I would have really hated that subplot. Gibby trying to get a $5 bill? -_- I kept thinking there would be some twist but there wasn't. Gibby really doesn't have any significance to the plots of the show anymore, he is just...there. Just for the sake of being there and being a regular. He isn't Gibby anymore... The plot to this was predictable too, but it was still alright. I guess.

I enjoyed the episode but wasn't crazy about Gibby's subplot. Lots of great lines and funny moments.

The episode was OK but I didn't like the Gibby sub-plot & the fact that they showed the groom wetting himself at his own wedding. It was overkill to do that since you could already see he was nervous & IMO it wasn't funny. Then we are supposed to believe he doesn't at least run off to change but instead stands in his own pee and the wedding continues, sure.

that woman deciding she wanted to marry spencer didn't feel legit to me. It felt like she had a crush on him, which she obviously did, but that doesn't mean she would literally want to get married. it's like when you have a crush on a person from a movie or tv show, you like them and you might joke about wanting to marry them, but you don't really want to.

also, am I the only one who finds guppy's "Happy birthday!" more annoying than funny? In iPsycho it was funny because sam, carly and freddie played the message for Gibby and so Guppy heard them say it to him, but now it's overkill. i'm all for having Guppy appear on this show, but they need more lines. His funniest part for me was when the girl walked by and he took the picture of her. That was funny and that had nothing to do with him saying "Happy birthday." I really hope, if he does start to appear in more episodes, that he says more than that. It's gonna get old real fast (For me it already has).

Do you guys realize that Spencer was the first person that said "Happy Birthday" to Gibby? What episode was it in...It's Season 2...the one where Gibby helps Spencer train to be on the football team. Anyways...I just now watched iDo. It was okay but the subplot was horrible. I basically agree with almost all of Futuramarama's post.

I think Gibby is part of the main cast incase one of Jen or Nathan want to quit the show, whilst Miranda and the other of Jen/Nathan want to keep going.

They'll bump Gibby up to the main trio and keep going as usual.

Didn't he ask the fans if they thought Gibby should be a main character though? Of course it was ultimately Dan's decision...

I thought it was because he's been in almost every episode at least once in the past, like, season-and-a-half. IMO.

It'd be kind of upsetting if he replaced either Nathan or Jen.

I don't remember exactly. I still retain that I like him better as a minor character. :/

Wait...why would he replace Nathan or Jennette?

I don't like when main characters disappear or get replaced. If that happens I'm going into denial.

no way they'd have gibby replace freddie or sam. that happens i quit the show

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wOs4AXbBUUI

A creddie review of this episode.

i don't hate gibby but it would be dumb if he replaced freddie or sam, as they are the originals on the show. gibby is obviously important to the show, but he isn't as useful on the web show (almost every single time he is on it is too poke fun at him)

I'm with Futurama on this one. Whenever one character would take the place of a main character on other shows, they just went downhill (imo). I can't think of too many off the back, but I know it's happened before.

So, hopefully, that doesn't happen.