We all know that the creators were aiming to make 3 seasons (though if they could have known how popular it would be after taking off then they may have aimed for more). I also heard that they were aiming to make 3 seasons and possibly more if it took off, but even though it clearly has I still haven't heard anything about a book 4.
I've heard that they're considering running a spin-off, instead.
The problem with spin-offs is that when the average fan either hasn't heard that it's a spin off before its launch or, if they do know it's a spin off they're disappointed when it lacks certain characters that they have grown fond of, or the lack of those characters signifies that a change has happened in the story line since the end of the original series and the beginning of the spin-off series (eg, some characters you hoped would get together didn't, a character you really liked died, or the lack of explanation just bothers you).
So, if you were Michael DiMartino or Bryan Konietzko and decided to make a 4th season, what would you do?
I haven't seen Sozin's Comet yet (please don't spoil it for me), but I assume that either Aang survived and the fire nation was defeated or Aang was defeated and either died at the Fire Lords hands or was seriously injured and has to try to defeat him again.
I think it was the first option, Aang defeated the fire nation and lived.
The reason I think this is because the Avatar cycle will be broken if Aang dies. And I'm not talking about dying while he's in the Avatar state, I mean just plain dying. The name of the show is "The Last Airbender". When he dies he'll be reborn into one of the water tribes, the earth kingdom, the fire nation (or possibly the Sun Warriors) and then... What?
I think that it would be kind of cool if the 4th season started off kinda slow, what with the dramatic climax of a 4 part end to the previous season. Aang has to found a whole new air nation, so he starts looking for potential candidates. However something like that doesn't offer the same kind of global threat that the march of the fire nation offered. But I guess, as Avatar, he would still be dealing with the after effects of the fire war anyway (how can you not have a century long war and not be hostile against its instigators?)
Still, a new series based on peace making discussions and training new characters how to bend air doesn't make for the most interesting of programmes There has to be a new threat, and hopefully one that isn't totally apparent, at first, but becomes more so as the seasons progress and the problems related to it become more serious.
But this threat would need to be something bigger than the fire nation. Some people might conclude that the only thing more serious than that is 2 (or more) other nations, but that's just doing the same thing all over again on a larger scale.
That leaves the spirit world.
So, if I was making a new season it would be; "Book 4; Air". Aang, possibly an older Aang, has decided to teach new students air bending. Unbeknown to him there is a sinister plot, somewhere in the world; a secret organization (NOT the white lotus, as they're pretty obviously 'good guys' ) is plotting to make an attack directly on the spirit world.
Aang once again needs assistance, this time from ones who had had first hand experience with the spirits. Aside from the previous Avatars this includes Iroh, who has been to the spirit world and seems to have the ability to see spirits (he saw Aang on Roku's dragon) and the Guru (don't remember his name).
But ok, let's say there are 3 more seasons based on humans attacking the spirit world, what then? What if the need for more is still there after that and nobody knows where it can go?
The only thing I can think of is the spirits turning on the physical world. I haven't really given this much thought, but it would be cool if this was lead by Koh (the face stealer, particularly sinister) who was gathering allies among the spirits to attack the physical world.
All comments and alternative ideas welcome