Nickelodeon (ended 2008)
KilalaRose wrote: |
Firebenders can bend lightning, lava, and magma, and, well, fire, because they are all forms of plasmas. We don't know whether or not Earthbenders can bend magma/lava, but I don't think they can because once the natural impurities are taken out of their element, they aren't able to bend it. But we do know that both Waterbenders and Earthbenders can bend mud (see "The Drill"). But next time, ask this in the Ask A Question, Get An Answer Thread at the top of the forum. Thank you. |
Taang_Forever wrote: |
Nope. There is no evidence whatsoever that a regular non-avatar master firebender can bend magma. And those that have been shown(or mentioned) to have done so, WERE avatars, so there is no concrete proof. Still, it owuld seem pointless to have put a firenation-born avatar bending magma in a slide show showing other avatars bending their nation's element, if he's just bending the earth along with it. It diminishes the firenation-Avatar's showing of his first element's mastery. Did any of that make sense? |
Well maybe it's like that situation in 'The Drill' where both Katara and Toph were bending the slurry water that contained rocks, mud, and water. If it contains the element, they can bend it. This is my assumption.
agnai wrote: |
Well maybe it's like that situation in 'The Drill' where both Katara and Toph were bending the slurry water that contained rocks, mud, and water. If it contains the element, they can bend it. This is my assumption. |
mithrandir11 wrote: |
Okay, first of all, why just because we have only seen the Avatar bend lava, does that mean that JUST the avatar can bend lava. Now, Magma actually turns into lava. The moment magma leaves the ground, it is lava. So, they actually just bend lava, except for pulling it out of a volcano. Thirdly, I think that the Avatar would be less of a master at firebending than a plain master firebender. I mean, the Avatar only has one lifetime to learn and master all four bending disciplines, whereas the master firebender has one lifetime to master just firebending. If anyone could bend lava, it would be a master firebender. Then the Avatar. |
I don't know, I mean, Katara became a master at her element in what, like a few weeks? A few months, tops. What's to stop the Avatar from mastering the other elements in a short time too and then spend the rest of his life at firebending? Though I see your point, either way the firebender has maybe a few decades to learn over the Avatar. But if it turns out that a little earthbending is needed to bend magma, then the Avatar would have him there. I'm leaning towards thinking that master firebenders can bend magma.
Taang_Forever wrote: | ||
I don't know, I mean, Katara became a master at her element in what, like a few weeks? A few months, tops. What's to stop the Avatar from mastering the other elements in a short time too and then spend the rest of his life at firebending? Though I see your point, either way the firebender has maybe a few decades to learn over the Avatar. But if it turns out that a little earthbending is needed to bend magma, then the Avatar would have him there. I'm leaning towards thinking that master firebenders can bend magma. |
Taang_Forever wrote: |
I don't know, I mean, Katara became a master at her element in what, like a few weeks? A few months, tops. What's to stop the Avatar from mastering the other elements in a short time too and then spend the rest of his life at firebending? Though I see your point, either way the firebender has maybe a few decades to learn over the Avatar. But if it turns out that a little earthbending is needed to bend magma, then the Avatar would have him there. I'm leaning towards thinking that master firebenders can bend magma. |
Don't get it twisted. Katara became master to Aang, but she isn't a Master the way Pakku and Jeong Jeong is. Call it being an "Honorary" aster. She's far too young to be a real Master as that takes experience.
Lachlaan wrote: |
Maybe the producers just made a little mistake when they showed that avatar bending the lava. They were probably going more for effect rather than for scientific acuracy. |