The Independents were a team consisting of users not a part of either the Drasticals or the Band Geeks. The team was formed July 1, 2016 and typically performs poorly in events due to having less people, inconsistent membership, and lack of participation. Occasionally referred to as the "Indies," the Independents won their first event in SpongeBash with 11 points. Additionally, they finished second in May Mayhem with 4 points, narrowly beating out the Band Geeks with 3 points. The highest number of points the Indies have ever won was in their first event as a team where they posted 25 points (a distant third behind the Drasticals's runner-up 44 points). They were disbanded on February 7th, 2020.
Event Showings
| Event | Points | Result | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Super Spongy Square Games | 66-44-25 | Loss; 3rd place | First appearance |
| Octerror Fest 2016 | 21-14-3 | Loss; 3rd place | |
| Snowcember Ball 2016 | 23-20-7 | Loss; 3rd place | |
| March Madness 2017 | 32-25-3 | Loss; 3rd place | |
| May Mayhem | 11-4-3 | Loss; 2nd place | |
| Octerror Fest 2017 | 29-17-4 | Loss; 3rd place | |
| Snowcember Ball 2017 | 37-30-3 | Loss; 3rd place | |
| March Madness 2018 | 43-21-5 | Loss; 3rd place | |
| Sponge Cup | 48-35-5 | Loss; 3rd place | |
| Octerror Fest 2018 | 34-31-7 | Loss; 3rd place | |
| Snowcember Ball 2018 | 32-29-13 | Loss; 3rd place | |
| March Madness 2019 | 31-28-14 | Loss; 3rd place | |
| SpongeBash | 11-8-6 | Win | Independents first win, Most dominant win; 3 points over the Band Geeks |
| Octerror Fest 2019 | 20-10-8 | Loss; 3rd place | |
| Snowcember Ball 2019 | 22-20-8 | Loss; 3rd place | Last appearance |