No, I agree with you completely. I could see the relationship working better if they were to reunite in season 1 rather than in season 2. Even if Courtney wouldn't have made it much further, she was at least human enough to help jump-start a healthy relationship. Although, the answer as to why this would happen is simple: They would have to be on the same team.
And I also personally believe that the episode was a little to rushed in terms with their relationship. Seeing as Duncan is usually willing to put up with anything Courtney does to him, I would have expected her to do something that was really heinous to him. But on the other hand, since Duncan was so sleep deprived, nothing really happened between the two. He basically vocalized his feelings about her demands and Courtney called the shots from there by breaking up with him. Although, like most teen relationships, them getting back together is probably most likely to happen. I'm sure that Courtney is going to have to work to gain a bit of Duncan's trust again, but I could see them getting back together in an instant.
Edited on 11/26/2009 1:50pm